Consumer Focus shows red-card to huge World Cup mobile phone fees

Consumer Focus is warning that thousands of England fans travelling to the 2010 FIFA World Cup could face huge mobile phone bills. Costs for calls, texts and data use could add up to over £100 on a match-day, more than the £55-£80 face value of a ticket.1

Figures compiled by the consumer champion2 show that customers could face particularly big fees for uploading photos or videos to social networking sites during the contest. Costs to use mobile internet of £1.25 to £8 per MB could leave customers paying, for example, up to £80 just to upload ten photos to Facebook. Charges to make calls range from 80p up to £1.50 per minute and texts cost from 25p to 50p.

These costs are substantially higher than those for UK travellers in the EU, where costs are capped at 37p per minute for making calls, 9p for a text and £42.50 for data roaming.3 These caps have been imposed on firms to stop excessive roaming rates for consumers travelling in Europe, but consumers travelling outside the EU can still face huge fees.

The network offering the best World Cup call rates is Vodafone. By opting into its free ‘Passport’ scheme before they leave the country UK customers pay a 75p connection fee to make or receive calls and then pay their normal UK rates. 3 UK offers the cheapest data roaming fees of £1.25 per MB and Vodafone Passport offers the best value texts at 11p each followed by Virgin Media at 25p per text for pay monthly customers.  T-Mobile’s free ‘World Class’ scheme offers calls to the UK for 55p per minute for customers roaming on the MTN network in South Africa.

The worst rates for making calls are offered by Virgin Media pre-pay at £1.70 per minute, T-mobile at £1.50 and Orange at £1.45 per minute. T-mobile is also the most expensive network to receive calls on at £1.50 per minute to receive a call from the UK. The highest data charges are from Orange and Tesco, with costs for customers on both networks of up to £80 to upload ten 1MB photos, closely followed by T-mobile with a similar figure of £75.

Nick Hutton, telecommunications expert for Consumer Focus, said:

“England fans need to be on the ball to make sure they don’t get caught out by hundreds of pounds of hidden mobile phone costs at the World Cup. We want to see mobile phone firms play fair by customers travelling abroad and cut these extremely high fees. In the meantime consumers should check their network rates before they fly and look into the add-ons or bundles on offer, which could save them much needed cash.”

The watchdog is calling on mobile phone firms to cut their mobile-phone roaming costs and set prices at a similar level to those in the EU. Consumer Focus is also urging consumers to find out about charges, and look at bundles for data, calls and text costs, before they depart for South Africa to ensure they don’t get hit with a huge bill on their return.

Consumer Focus’s top five mobile phone tips for England fans:

  • Check your rates before you go, as these will be much higher in South Africa than in the UK and Europe, and ask what add-ons or bundles your mobile phone company offers on calls, texts and data as this could make you considerable savings
  • Remember that while abroad you won’t be able to use your inclusive minutes, texts and data allowance (except inclusive minutes under Vodafone’s passport service) and will pay to receive as well as to make calls which could add up
  • Photos and videos can be expensive to upload on mobiles while abroad so consider other options such as uploading using a computer at an internet cafe or hotel instead, or use the option to upload via multimedia messaging (MMS) if available on your network
  • You could consider getting a local SIM card for use in South Africa if you will be making calls to numbers within the country
  • If your phone is lost or stolen while abroad report it to your mobile provider as soon as possible as you will be liable for any calls made. Make a note of the emergency contact number for your network and keep this separate from your mobile. 

ENDS 

Notes to editors:

  1. Consumer Focus calculated costs for an English mobile phone user in South Africa on a realistic match day scenario. The scenario used is as follows: Phoning home in the morning to speak to your partner / kids – 5 mins, calling a friend in to arrange where to meet before the game – 3 mins, making 6 texts during the game, a call home to bemoan a 4-3 loss or celebrate a Rooney hattrick – 7 mins,  uploading 10 pictures to your On Tour with England blog site, calling to say goodnight to your partner / kids 2 mins.

Ticket prices are available on the FIFA website

3 £39.80
O2 £76.25 (contract)
£79.77 (pre-pay)
Orange £107.65
T-Mobile £102.90
Tesco Mobile £97.53
Virgin Media £68.50 (contract)
£81 (pre-pay)
Vodafone £30.69 (contract)
£31.53 (pre-pay)
  1. Please see tables below for the full compilation of figures. These figures are compiled from data from the seven biggest UK mobile providers in May 2010.
  2. EU roaming caps are outlined below. The caps for calls came into effect as of  June 2007, July 2009 for texts and the data roaming limit is effective as of 1 March 2010:
Making a call within the EU Maximum tariff of €0.43/min Equivalent to 37p
Receiving a call within the EU Maximum tariff of €0.19/min 16p
Sending a text within the EU Maximum tariff of €0.11 per text 9p
Data roaming within the EU  New cut-off mechanism when bill reaches approx.€50 or alternative limit set by user £42.50

 

Headline rates for using mobile phones in South Africa in June / July 2010

Available Add-ons

3 UK       N/A
O2 International Traveller service: reductions in the cost of making and receiving calls (£3 per month) Contract customers onlyData Abroad bolt-on:10MB data use / £20 per month

50MB data use / £50 per month

Contract / iPhone customers only

Orange World Traveller bundle: 20% discount on making and receiving calls and sending texts; £5 per month, contract customers only.Global travel data bundle:5MB data / £17.50 per month

10MB / £35 per month

50MB / £88.13 per month

200MB / £135 per month

Contract customers only

T-mobile International Option: Receiving calls £1pm instead of £1.50pm; £2.50 per month (contract customers only)World Class: Calls to the UK for 55p/min when roaming on the MTN network.  Available for free to contract customers apart from U-Fix
Tesco N/A
Virgin Media N/A
Vodafone Vodafone Passport: 75p to make or receive a call, then same as UK price plan.  Free to opt in by calling 5555 from Vodafone mobile.  Open to contract and pre-pay customers.
 
  Calling a UK landline from South Africa Receiving a call from a UK landline Sending a text to the UK Mobile data roaming
  Contract Pre-pay Contract Pre-pay Contract Pre-pay Contract Pre-pay
3 UK £1.40pm £1.40pm 99ppm 99ppm 35p 35p £1.25 / MB £1.25 / MB
O2 85ppm 99ppm £1.11pm 99ppm 30p 49p £6 / MB £6 / MB
Orange £1.45pm £1.45pm 90ppm 90ppm 50p 50p £8 / MB £8 / MB
T-Mobile £1.50pm £1.50.pm £1.50pm £1.50pm 40p 40p £7.50 / MB £7.50 / MB
Tesco 89ppm 89ppm 89ppm 89ppm 40p 40p £8 / MB £8 / MB
Virgin Media £1pm £1.70pm 50ppm 80ppm 25p 35p £5 / MB £5 / MB
Vodafone  80ppm  80ppm  75ppm   75ppm   35p.   49p   Up to £14.99 for 25MBFrom 15 June: £3 / MB up to 5MB* Up to £14.99 for 25MBFrom 15 June: £3 / MB up to 5MB
* First MB charged up to £14.99 in 1KB steps, then the next 24MB are free. From 15th June: £3 per MB for the first 5MB and £15 for every subsequent 5MB.

  

Scenarios 3 UK O2 Orange T-Mobile Tesco Virgin Media Vodafone
Making a 5 minute call to a UK landline  Contract £7Pre-pay £7 Contract £4.25Pre-pay £4.95Add-on £3.25

 

Contract £7.25Pre-pay £7.25Add-on £5.80 Contract £7.50Pre-pay £7.50Add-on £2.75 Contract £4.45Pre-pay £4.45 Contract £5Pre-pay £8.50 Contract £4Pre-pay £4Add-on 75p – £1.75
Receiving a 5 minute call from a UK landline  Contract £4.95Pre-pay £4.95 Contract £5.55Pre-pay £4.95Add-on £2.50 Contract £4.50Pre-pay £4.50Add-on £3.60 Contract £7.50Pre-pay £7.50Add-on £5 (cheaper after 5 mins) Contract £4.45Pre-pay £4.45 Contract £2.50Pre-pay £4 Contract £3.75Pre-pay £3.75Add-on 75p
Using 1MB of mobile data (browsing approx 15 standard / 40 mobile-friendly web pages)  Contract £1.25Pre-pay £1.25 Contract £6Pre-pay £6Add-on £2 (10MB data bolt-on) Contract £8Pre-pay £8Add-on £3.50 (5MB data bundle) Contract £7.50Pre-pay £7.50Add-on – unlimited data £15 per month (Blackberry only) Contract £8Pre-pay £8 Contract £5Pre-pay £5 Contract £14.99Pre-pay £14.99From 15 June:

Contract £3

Pre-pay £3

Uploading 10 x 1MB photos to Facebook (10MB total)  Contract £12.50Pre-pay £12.50 Contract £60Pre-pay £60Add-on £20 Contract £80Pre-pay £80Add-on £35 Contract £75Pre-pay £75Add-on – unlimited data £15 per month (Blackberry only) Contract £80Pre-pay £80 Contract £50Pre-pay £50 Contract £14.99Pre-pay £14.99From 15 June:

Contract £30

Pre-pay £30